Increased Medicare Advantage Penetration Is Associated With Lower Postacute Care Use For Traditional Medicare Patients

health-affairs-journal on PayerIndex
Our Take: A Health Affairs study finds that as Medicare Advantage market penetration rises, traditional Medicare beneficiaries in the same markets also see reduced post-acute care use – a “spillover” effect driven by providers adjusting their practice patterns in response to MA incentives. This change occurs without a corresponding increase in hospital readmissions.  ▼

For skilled nursing facilities, the finding means MA growth is reshaping care norms across the entire market, compressing referral volume for both MA and traditional Medicare patients regardless of a facility’s MA contract status.

SNFs in high-MA-penetration markets should anticipate declining post-acute referral volume across all payer types as providers normalize reduced PAC utilization, and those operating in ACO-aligned markets face compounded pressure — the study found the spillover effect was strongest where traditional Medicare beneficiaries were attributed to accountable care organizations.


Increased Medicare Advantage Penetration Is Associated With Lower Postacute Care Use for Traditional Medicare Patients

Medicare Advantage (MA) plans, which accounted for 45 percent of total Medicare enrollment in 2022, are incentivized to minimize spending on low-value services. Prior research indicates that MA plan enrollment is associated with reduced postacute care use without adverse impacts on patient outcomes. However, it is unclear whether a rising MA enrollment level is associated with a change in postacute care use in traditional Medicare, especially given growing participation in traditional Medicare Alternative Payment Models that have been found to be associated with lower postacute care spending.

We hypothesize that market-level MA expansion is associated with reduced postacute care use among traditional Medicare beneficiaries — a “spillover” effect of providers modifying their practice patterns in response to MA plans’ incentives. We found increased MA market penetration associated with reduced postacute care use among traditional Medicare beneficiaries, without a corresponding increase in hospital readmissions. This association was generally stronger in markets with a greater share of traditional Medicare beneficiaries attributed to accountable care organizations, suggesting that policy makers should account for MA penetration when evaluating potential savings in Alternative Payment Models within traditional Medicare.

— Health Affairs, Apr. 2023

Geng, Fangli, et al. “Increased Medicare Advantage Penetration Is Associated With Lower Postacute Care Use for Traditional Medicare Patients.” Health Affairs, vol. 42, no. 4, Apr. 2023, pp. 488–497. https://doi.org/10.1377/hlthaff.2022.00994.

More Posts Like This One

Find More Medicare Advantage Resources